Friday, February 8, 2008

John Merrill

As many great journalists know, plagiarism is a big no. Many would think that one of the oldest professors in journalism at the University of Missouri would know better. This is why a controversy was been sparked regarding John Merrill, a great journalist whose work has been published throughout the country. This past November, Merrill turned an objective article written by a student, into a column full of his own ideas about women's and gender studies. Yet, what raised the plagiarism flag was the fact that he used every quote from the article and did not give the original writer credit for the source of the quotes.
I personally believe that Merrill did not plagiarize. He used quotes; a quote has to be exactly the same because it is what the person said. I also feel it was inappropriate for a student to a attack an established professor, I feel that she over stepped her boundaries by making such a big deal out of the article. I feel bad for Miller that he was fired and that his name will be branded forever as being a person who plagiarizes instead of just being remembered as a great professor and journalist.

1 Comments:

At February 9, 2008 at 7:17 AM , Blogger Rosemary Armao said...

Thanks for this posting.

A few things I would debate with you.

*I think the controversy is partly over whether the punishment fits the crime. You are right that Merrill did not steal IDEAS. He did not present as his the thinking of another. That is the classic crime for which harsh punishment is right. But Merrill did present as accurate quotes he never heard spoken and did got give credit to the reporter from whom he took them. He called that technical plagarism. It's wrong, but the feeling of many is that it's less wrong than stealing ideas. It's a misdemeanor, not a felony.

*So was the student wrong to call this matter into question? Boy I do not think so. Schools rightly try to hammer in the idea that you must not plagiarize and here she believed herself to be plagiarized and by a highly respected professor. She did not overstep any bounds. ASKING QUESTIONS IS ALWAYS GOOD IN JOURNALISM.

*The lesson of this incident is that you don't have to be evil, stupid or bad to plagiarize. You can just be careless. So, be careful. Do full research, use the work of other thinkers and build on it -- but be careful in how you present your product.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home